For Jimmy Rollins, leadership has been in knowing when to step aside

This article originally appeared in Sports Illustrated in 2015.

“I’m not gonna get down, I’m not gonna get defeated. I’m not gonna get depressed and ‘oh, woe is me.’ I have a job to do.”

— Jimmy Rollins

The quote was delivered with the bluntness of an aging warrior at peace with his fate.
His turn in the limelight was coming to an end. It was time to pass the baton, and while he
perhaps wasn’t entirely O.K. with it, he at least understood.

They’re going to play him.

Jimmy Rollins

The message came from Jimmy Rollins, the 17-year veteran, a former MVP and World Series
Champion now committed to career twilight with the Los Angeles Dodgers. The “him” in
question: Corey Seager, a lanky 21-year-old shortstop with a smooth left-handed stroke
reminiscent of John Olerud.

Much to the delight of a fan base grown antsy after a 27-year championship drought, the
Dodgers had decided the kid would get the bulk of the playing time the rest of the way —
including in the playoffs.

Perhaps encouraged by a bit of prodding from above, Dodgers manager Don Mattingly has
since reaffirmed on the switch, batting Seager third in Game 1 against of the NL Division
Series against the New York Mets, and second in Game 2.

So far, the returns have been more or less a push. Seager—foiled like the rest of his
teammates were by the red hot Jacob deGrom — was 1-for-4 with two strikeouts in a 3–1 loss
in Game 1. His lone hit was a harmless fly ball Seager thought was tailing foul, until the
Mets’ Michael Cuddyer badly misplayed it into a double. In the field, Seager saw only one
opportunity come his way — a routine Juan Lagares grounder in the ninth. He butchered the
throw, but was bailed out when first baseman Adrian Gonzalez deftly handled the inbetween hop.

He looked more relaxed in the Dodgers’ 5–2 Game 2 victory, however. He went 0-for-4 at the
plate, but handled each of his fielding attempts flawlessly, including a nice over-the-shoulder
basket catch in the second inning to rob Lucas Duda of a momentum-sparking hit. As for Rollins, he went 0-for-1 in a pinch-hit appearance in Game 1 and didn’t leave the
bench in Game 2.

Still, regardless of the postseason impacts Seager and Rollins might have, the switch was
about much more than what happens this October. It was about developing talent and
playing for the future — necessary considerations even for one of the richest teams in all of
baseball. Truth be told, many also view the move as a matter of necessity, a recognition of an
end to a failed experiment. When you look at the numbers, it’s not hard to see why: Rollins is
coming off a season in which he registered career lows in just about every major statistic,
including batting average (.224), on-base percentage (.285) and OPS (.643).

All of which can be trumped, in the hearts and minds of the Dodger faithful, by a simple nod:
Rollins has done everything that’s been asked of him.

Given L.A.’s reputation as a paragon of analytics, this might seem like an odd sentiment to
have. After all, how could guys like Andrew Friedman, whom the Dodgers poached from
Tampa Bay, and Farhan Zaidi, who studied under Billy Beane, be content with the
.224/.285/.358 slashline that Rollins presented? While they certainly weren’t thrilled with
Rollins’ plate prowess, Friedman and Zaidi were looking at things with a much more
nuanced eye than you might expect.

The most obvious observation is that Rollins — a career .265 hitter — was brought in mostly
for his defense. And while the 36-year-old was never going to be the Gold Glover of seasons
past, he certainly struck a better facsimile pose than his predecessor, the disinterested potted
plant known as Hanley Ramirez. Simply put, Rollins got to nearly all the balls he was
supposed to get to, and made nearly all the plays he was supposed to make—while pulling an
occasional rabbit out of the hat.

The second reason Rollins was brought aboard was for his leadership — another marked
improvement over Ramirez. You could see it as early as spring training, when the longtime
Phillie sought out budding superstar Yasiel Puig for what turned into a two-hour
conversation. This was no veteran fire-and-brimstone lashing, but rather a genuine attempt
to get to know a young lightning rod capable of dazzling and frustrating in near-equal

“From what I see and what I’ve heard, he’s inserting himself into more of a team role instead
of just ‘66 — Yasiel Puig,’” Rollins said at the time. “That’s good for everybody, but even more
so it’s good for him. You get the guys on your team to like you and respect you, the outside
will follow. That’s the way it is. And the organization will see it, be able to see you as a
person not just as a talent.”

Third, Rollins was asked — tacitly, perhaps, but with writing on the wall all the while — to
hold a spot for Seager until he was ready, and to step aside gracefully once he was. During a session with reporters in August, just as he was finally beginning to emerge from a
horrible, three-month hitting slump, Rollins spoke about his ability to keep a level head, to
find ways to contribute despite his struggles at the plate.

“I’m not gonna get down, I’m not gonna get defeated,” he said. “I’m not gonna get depressed
and ‘oh, woe is me.’ I have a job to do. The pitchers rely on me to catch the ball, my
teammates rely on me to catch the balls, make the plays, to make sure guys are in the right
position, to make sure I’m doing things right. I have to do those things. The other part, you
have to just believe that it will come. You keep working and you trust that it shows up on the
field as far as results. And it’s like, ‘Wow, all that work finally paid off.’ That doesn’t matter if
you’ve played one year, or 30 years, that’s always going to be the case. But you have to find a
way to contribute somehow and I was able to keep that part going until the hitting caught

The hitting never quite caught up, but that kind of team-first attitude quickly drew the
respect of Dodgers management — a respect that has since been returned in kind. At one
point during the season’s dog days, just as Seager was beginning to tear up Triple-A, a team
official defended to me the team’s decision to stick with Rollins and wait until rosters
expanded in September to promote Seager.

If you call up Seager now, he reasoned, you have to sit Rollins, and the veteran is too
valuable to risk having him check out on the team early in the season.

“What if the kid comes up and struggles in his first two weeks?” he posited. “Now you’ve lost
Jimmy, and you’re in trouble. Then what do you do?”

It was a fair point at the time. Since then, the plan has gone almost perfectly. Following his
September call up, Seager quickly saw an increase in playing time (thanks in no small part to
a Rollins injury) and began raking the ball. Meanwhile, the Dodgers breezed to a third
straight NL West crown down the stretch, clinching home-field advantage in the NLDS in the

The veteran knew the score. He saw his role about to change, and he faced it like any good
professional would. He said all the right things: that he was fine with the team’s decision;
that the name on the front of the jersey mattered far more than the one on the back.
Coming from most, the statements could’ve easily sounded cliché. But it’s in the consistency
of Rollins’ statements — the same sense of grace and leadership from Day 1 on — that Dodgers
fans have found reason to believe their new shortstop’s ascension will continue to be

“Either you’re selfish or you’re a man of your word,” Rollins recently told the LA Times. “If
you say it’s about the team, then when the situation isn’t necessarily in your favor, you
shouldn’t change. I’m not going to change.”

The Dodgers brought Rollins to LA for three simple reasons: to play defense, to lead the
clubhouse, and to step out of the spotlight once their franchise phenom was ready.

In the end, Rollins gave the Dodgers everything they asked for. But it’s the above and beyond
— how much more his words and manner have meant — that could end up paying the biggest
dividends of all.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s